6061284545_8d274bfa8e_o.jpg

A recent automobile insurance case in Maine was a victory for fine print. The Dairyland Insurance Company came up against someone who had provided false information on their insurance documents and purchased auto insurance in a different state than the one they were living in. In some cases, an insurance policy cannot be rescinded, which makes this case particularly interesting in the insurance industry.

There are, however, rules regarding falsifying information in order to receive insurance discounts, better rates, and other benefits. As McArthur Sullivan found out, legal fees cost a lot more than just paying a bit extra for your automobile insurance in the first place.

The Case

The case involved a man named McArthur Sullivan, who had purchased multiple personal car insurance policies for his vehicles. He purchased these policies and, on his insurance contract, stated that he lived in Wales, Maine, and kept his cars there as well.

Dairyland Insurance Company, found out that Sullivan had misrepresented himself with the personal information he had given them in order to insure his vehicles. Rather than living and storing his vehicles in Maine, as he had previously stated, evidence was found that he lived in Massachusetts and garaged his vehicles there as well.

The Insurance Company then sought to rescind the insurance policies they had given Sullivan, which resulted in a court case when Sullivan protested the nullification of his existing auto insurance policies.

A federal district court in Maine tried the case and found that an insurance company can pull a policy if the policy was based on false information provided by the person seeking insurance coverage. The application for Sullivan’s insurance policy included a statement that said that any false, incomplete, or misleading information put on the application could lead to consequences that included imprisonment, fines, or a denial of insurance benefits.

Dairyland also provided documentation that stated their right to rescind any insurance policy that was based on misrepresentation or circumstances that affected an applicant’s eligibility of risk (such as where they and their cars reside). This also includes situations where the insurance policy premium is lower than what they would pay if they had provided correct information.

For instance, if Sullivan had purchased auto insurance for his vehicles in Massachusetts, his payments would have been higher than he was paying in Maine.

Maine law also backs up Dairyland’s claims. Maine’s laws state that an insurance carrier can indeed pull an insurance policy that was given as a result of omissions or false information.

The Result

Dairyland won the court case due to the amount of evidence it had that stated a person must provide accurate information about themselves and their vehicles in order for the insurance policy to be considered valid. Maine law and Dairyland’s own insurance contracts provided a foundation for the court case to be heard in a federal court.

Dairyland was able to prove that Sullivan misrepresented himself on purpose and with the intention of gaining benefits from the false information he put in his application. The court found that Dairyland would not have issued an insurance policy to Sullivan based on the actual facts he would have put in his application, had he truthfully represented himself and his situation. The court upheld Dairyland’s decision to rescind Sullivan’s automobile insurance policies.

This case could have further implications not only for the auto insurance industry, but for other insurance policies as well. If someone is issued an insurance policy based on false or withheld information in their profile, an insurance company could be well within their rights to take away that insurance coverage if the person is found to have falsified application information.


THE SKYLINE DIFFERENCE

Other brokerages take a cookie cutter approach to insurance and outfit their customers with generic coverage.  Skyline is different.  We believe insurance should be built on innovation and experience. We appreciate the fact that every engagement is unique and understand proper coverage requires a deep understanding of the underlying business and individual.

"The opportunity to safeguard your concerns is a privilege we never take for granted."